Ali Shahrokh Isfahani
M.A. in Human Rights, Allameh Tabataba’i University
Introduction
Housing is one of the most fundamental human needs and an essential component of a decent standard of living. Accordingly, the right to adequate housing is recognized under both domestic and international law. The enjoyment of this right extends beyond merely having a roof over one’s head to encompass safety, habitability, security of tenure, access to essential services and infrastructure, and an adequate location. Under Iranian law, the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran likewise recognizes the importance of housing in meeting basic needs and protecting the inviolability of the home, while obligating the State to establish the conditions necessary to ensure access to housing appropriate to the needs of individuals and families.
In recent years, the increasing prevalence of land subsidence across various parts of Iran has raised new concerns regarding the realization of the right to adequate housing. Land subsidence, particularly when caused by excessive groundwater extraction, is not merely a geological or environmental phenomenon. By damaging buildings and infrastructure, compromising safety and habitability, reducing property values, and, in severe cases, necessitating the evacuation and relocation of residents, it can directly affect individuals’ enjoyment of adequate housing.
Despite the existence of numerous laws and programs addressing disaster management, water resources, and housing, the persistence and expansion of land subsidence in Iran indicate that sufficient institutional and operational coordination has yet to be established among these sectors. Furthermore, where continued residence in high-risk areas poses serious threats to safety and health, greater attention must be given to the provision of adequate alternative housing and the protection of residents’ rights throughout the relocation process. Against this background, the central research question of this study is: What obligations does the Iranian State bear under the right to adequate housing in relation to the risks and consequences of land subsidence, and what legal and institutional challenges hinder the effective implementation of these obligations? The study hypothesizes that land subsidence, particularly when resulting from unsustainable water resource management, can undermine the safety and habitability of housing and thereby restrict the enjoyment of the right to adequate housing. Consequently, the State’s obligations extend beyond responding to damage after it occurs to encompass prevention and risk reduction, protection of individuals exposed to harm, and the adoption of appropriate measures for compensation and resettlement where necessary. Nevertheless, the fragmentation of institutional responsibilities, difficulties in achieving sustainable water resource management, and the absence of coherent mechanisms for protection and compensation pose significant challenges to the effective implementation of these obligations.
This study is organized into four sections. The first examines the legal framework of the right to adequate housing, including its legal foundations and the corresponding obligations of the State. The second explains the concept of land subsidence and the factors contributing to it, while examining its effects and consequences for the right to adequate housing. The third addresses the State’s obligations concerning the impact of land subsidence on this right, with particular emphasis on preventive measures, risk reduction, and the protection of residents in areas exposed to subsidence risks. Finally, the fourth section examines the policies and measures adopted by the Iranian State in response to the consequences of land subsidence and analyzes the principal legal and institutional challenges to the effective implementation of these obligations.
The Right to Adequate Housing under Domestic and International Law
Housing, alongside food, clothing, and healthcare, is among the most important components of human well-being and the fulfillment of basic human needs. In Islamic teachings, housing is not regarded merely as a material commodity. The Holy Qur’an states: “And Allah has made for you from your homes a place of rest” (The Holy Qur’an, 16:80). Furthermore, housing can be considered a fundamental human need with two dimensions, one related to human nature and creation and the other to religious prescriptions. On the one hand, dwelling in a safe and peaceful environment is intrinsically connected to fundamental human needs and the nature of human existence. On the other hand, the emphasis placed on housing in religious teachings provides a normative foundation for protecting this essential human interest. This understanding is also reflected in the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran, at least four articles of which specifically address the right to or need for housing. Article 3 identifies the “elimination of deprivation” in the area of “housing,” through the “establishment of a sound and just economy,” as one of the means of achieving the objectives of the Islamic Republic. Article 22 recognizes the inviolability of individuals’ homes, alongside their dignity, lives, property, and rights. Article 31 declares “housing commensurate with their needs” to be the right of every Iranian individual and family and obligates the State to establish the conditions necessary for its realization, giving priority to those most in need. Article 43 further identifies the provision of basic necessities, including housing, as an essential component of society’s economic independence and the eradication of poverty (Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran, 1989).
At the international level, the right to housing is recognized within the broader framework of the right to an adequate standard of living. Article 25(1) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights identifies housing as one of the essential elements of an adequate standard of living necessary for the health and well-being of individuals and their families (Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948). Article 11(1) of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) recognizes the right of every person to an adequate standard of living for themselves and their family, including adequate food, clothing and housing, as well as the continuous improvement of living conditions. It further requires States Parties to take appropriate steps to ensure the realization of this right, recognizing the essential importance of international cooperation based on free consent (ICESCR, 1966). Iran signed the Covenant on 4 April 1968 and ratified it on 24 June 1975 (United Nations Treaty Collection, 2026), giving it the force of domestic law in Iran (Civil Code of Iran, 1928). In interpreting the right to adequate housing, the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR), in its General Comment No. 4, emphasizes that the right to housing should not be interpreted narrowly or merely as the right to a roof over one’s head or basic shelter. Rather, it must be understood as the right to live in a place consistent with inherent human dignity and other human rights and freedoms. The General Comment further elaborates on the concept of housing “adequacy” through seven essential elements: “legal security of tenure,” “availability of services, materials, facilities and infrastructure,” “affordability,” “habitability,” “accessibility,” “location,” and “cultural adequacy” (CESCR, 1991). Under Article 2 of the ICESCR, States Parties undertake to guarantee the exercise of the rights recognized in the Covenant without discrimination of any kind on the grounds of race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth, or other status. They also undertake to take steps, individually and through international assistance and cooperation, particularly in the economic and technical fields, using the maximum of their available resources, with a view to progressively achieving the full realization of the rights recognized in the Covenant by all appropriate means, including the adoption of legislative measures.
Furthermore, the principle of non-retrogression in the realization of economic, social and cultural rights requires States to refrain from adopting measures that diminish individuals’ enjoyment of the rights guaranteed under the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. According to CESCR General Comment No. 3, any deliberately retrogressive measures “would require the most careful consideration” and would need to be fully justified in light of all the rights recognized in the Covenant and the full use of the maximum available resources (CESCR, 1990). This principle is particularly significant in relation to the right to adequate housing, as States cannot adopt policies or regulations that advance the interests of more privileged groups at the expense of undermining disadvantaged groups’ access to adequate housing. The Committee has further emphasized that “a general decline in living and housing conditions” resulting directly from States Parties’ policy and legislative decisions, without accompanying compensatory measures, would be inconsistent with their obligations under the Covenant (CESCR, 1991).
In Iran, government policymaking in the housing sector has a long history. Before the Islamic Revolution, beginning with the Third National Development Plan (1962–1968), housing was addressed as a distinct sector within national development planning. With the establishment of the Ministry of Development and Housing in 1963, policymaking and the coordination of measures related to housing and urban development became more systematic. The Fourth and Fifth Development Plans also established objectives aimed at increasing the housing supply, allocating government-owned land, and expanding construction activities. Following the Islamic Revolution, the Urban Wasteland Ownership Law (1979) and the Urban Land Law (1987), together with policies concerning land allocation and housing provision for low-income groups, constituted some of the government’s most significant measures in this field. Subsequently, the Law on Organizing and Supporting the Production and Supply of Housing (2008) obligated the government to provide land, banking facilities, and support for housing production for those without housing, particularly low-income groups. The Mehr Housing Program, followed by the Housing Production Leap Law (2021) and the National Housing Movement Program, continued this policy approach by seeking to increase the housing supply and improve access to housing for eligible groups.
Land Subsidence and Its Impacts on the Right to Adequate Housing
Given the significance of the right to adequate housing and the necessity of ensuring access to safe and habitable housing, hazards that threaten the physical stability of dwellings and the psychological well-being of residents can directly affect the realization of this right. One such hazard is land subsidence, generally defined as the vertical downward movement of the Earth’s surface, which may result from natural processes or human activities. Natural causes of subsidence include “tectonic activity,” “volcanic eruptions,” “rock dissolution,” “compaction of deep sediments,” and “ice melting.” However, “human activities” can cause “more rapid and severe subsidence” (Shafiei Darafshani & Shamsi Ezhieh, 2024: 28). Land subsidence is particularly significant in arid and semi-arid regions, where “continuous population growth” and the resulting increase in groundwater extraction for “domestic, agricultural, and even industrial uses” are among the principal factors contributing to its intensification. The consequences of this phenomenon, which become apparent gradually, are not limited to deformation of the Earth’s surface. They may also include fissures in the ground and buildings, ground collapse, foundation displacement, and cracking in residential, commercial, and administrative structures, as well as damage to agricultural and industrial facilities and roads. Moreover, in urban areas, these conditions may even pose risks to human life (Karimi et al., 2013: 39, 51–52). In addition to groundwater extraction, excessive extraction from mineral deposits and oil and gas fields can also contribute to the occurrence or intensification of land subsidence (Fatholahi et al., 2018: 24).
Today, 150 countries are affected by land subsidence, including the United States, Mexico, Egypt, Indonesia, and China. Iran is also among the countries experiencing this phenomenon on a widespread scale. The predominantly arid and semi-arid conditions across much of the country, declining water resources, population growth, and increasing human activities have created conditions conducive to the intensification of subsidence. According to existing studies, half of Iran’s plains are at risk of land subsidence, with excessive groundwater extraction identified as the most significant contributing factor nationwide. In addition to groundwater extraction, the weight of buildings and infrastructure, as well as extractive activities involving coal, oil, natural gas, and other mineral resources, may further exacerbate the situation. Tehran is among the most significant areas of concern due to its high population density, extensive construction activities, and substantial concentration of urban infrastructure. Alongside the principal causes of subsidence, the development of certain underground infrastructure, including metro tunnels, has also received attention in studies focusing on the city (Hesarakizad et al., 2024: 24, 31, 34). Given that earthquakes can intensify land subsidence, the simultaneous occurrence of subsidence and an earthquake in the metropolis of Tehran, particularly in an area characterized by “high population density,” an extensive concentration of buildings and urban facilities, and “numerous deteriorated urban areas,” could trigger a major crisis affecting not only Tehran but the entire country (Karimi et al., 2013: 53).
Among the various regions of Iran, Isfahan Province has also experienced a substantial expansion of land subsidence. The declining flow of the Zayandeh Rud River, industrial and agricultural development, population growth and migration, arid and semi-arid climatic conditions, and extensive groundwater extraction have all contributed to the intensification of this phenomenon. In addition to exposing transportation and communication, industrial, historical, and tourism infrastructure to damage, the consequences of land subsidence threaten the continuity of human activities and settlements. These consequences include cracking and tilting of buildings, damage to pipelines and sewerage networks, weakening of buildings and infrastructure, increased maintenance costs, declining land and property values, and disruptions to economic and social activities (Bagheri et al., 2022: 373, 378, 382).
Given the occurrence and expansion of land subsidence within urban areas, this phenomenon cannot be regarded merely as a geological or environmental issue. Rather, it must be understood as a factor affecting the safety, habitability, and continued enjoyment of adequate housing by residents. From this perspective, land subsidence is directly related to the element of “habitability” within the right to adequate housing, since threats to the safety and structural stability of buildings undermine residents’ sense of security and, where damage occurs, may lead to their evacuation or relocation, declining property values, and difficulties in securing alternative housing.
State Obligations to Guarantee and Implement the Right to Adequate Housing in the Face of Land Subsidence
Given that land subsidence can undermine the safety, structural stability, and habitability of buildings, thereby restricting individuals’ enjoyment of the right to adequate housing, measures to prevent this phenomenon and mitigate its consequences can be examined within the framework of the State’s obligations concerning this right. Furthermore, although land subsidence shares certain characteristics with natural disasters and climate change, it is not an exclusively natural phenomenon. Human factors, particularly water resource exploitation practices and development patterns, can contribute to its occurrence or intensification. Accordingly, the State’s responsibility for addressing the consequences of land subsidence cannot be confined to responding to damage after it occurs but must also encompass preventive and risk-reduction measures. On this basis, the State’s obligation to guarantee the right to adequate housing in the face of land subsidence, within the framework of its duty to refrain from adopting retrogressive measures affecting the realization of this right, can be examined from two perspectives: first, the obligation to monitor land conditions, prevent subsidence, and reduce associated risks; and second, the obligation to ensure safe relocation, where necessary, and provide adequate alternative housing for residents of high-risk areas.
- The Obligation to Monitor Land Conditions, Prevent Subsidence, and Reduce Associated Risks
The first step in protecting the right to housing against land subsidence is to prevent the phenomenon from intensifying and to mitigate the risks it poses. Preventive measures are particularly important because subsidence can reduce or permanently diminish the storage capacity of aquifers and subsurface pore spaces, while some of its consequences, especially where ground deformation becomes severe, may be irreversible or require considerable time to reverse. Consequently, in areas where subsidence is associated with declining groundwater levels, maintaining aquifer water levels and preventing excessive extraction must be central to preventive policies. Stabilizing groundwater levels can, over time, reduce the rate of subsidence and, under favorable conditions, bring it to a halt. Alongside these measures, predicting subsidence rates is also essential, as understanding the future progression of the phenomenon enables effective risk-reduction planning and the adoption of preventive measures (Saadat-Maqam & Iranpour Mobarakeh, 2025: 420–421).
Effective prevention of land subsidence also requires a coordinated set of measures across various sectors. Water resource management, soil resource management, the regulation and guidance of construction activities, comprehensive geological investigations, continuous monitoring and measurement, data analysis and subsidence forecasting, the development of applied research, and cooperation among responsible institutions are among the measures that can contribute to reducing the risks associated with this phenomenon. Experience in certain countries also demonstrates that active water resource management and aquifer recharge can be effective in controlling subsidence. For example, China has implemented measures to promote artificial aquifer recharge and regulate groundwater extraction. In Shanghai, reducing groundwater extraction and increasing artificial aquifer recharge have likewise been incorporated into management programs, helping not only to halt subsidence in the area but also to produce an uplift of the ground surface (Hesarakizad et al., 2024: 25, 36–37). Accordingly, addressing land subsidence requires a transition from responding to damage after it occurs toward preventive policymaking and integrated management of natural resources and land.
These requirements are particularly significant in Isfahan Province, given the severity and extent of land subsidence. In this province, reducing pressure on groundwater resources and preventing the intensification of human activities contributing to subsidence must be accompanied by spatial planning policies. Proposed measures for controlling the current trend include regulating population distribution, regulating industrial siting and development capacity and preventing disproportionate population growth in high-risk areas, restoring the flow of the Zayandeh Rud River, reforming cropping patterns, and improving the spatial planning of agricultural activities (Bagheri et al., 2022: 382–383). These measures demonstrate that land subsidence cannot be addressed solely through technical interventions after the phenomenon has occurred. Rather, it requires reforms in development patterns and the coordinated management of population, industry, agriculture, and water resources. Ultimately, such an approach can help prevent the growing vulnerability of human settlements and further threats to the right to adequate housing.
In addition to the direct human factors contributing to land subsidence, the relationship between this phenomenon and the effects of climate change on water resources must not be overlooked. Climate change, particularly through intensified droughts and increasing water stress in arid and semi-arid regions, can place additional pressure on groundwater resources. In areas where groundwater extraction exceeds the natural recharge capacity of aquifers, this pressure can exacerbate one of the factors contributing to subsidence. From this perspective, the protection of the right to adequate housing is closely connected to the right to water and the State’s obligations concerning climate change adaptation. In its 2025 Advisory Opinion, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) also recognized the close relationship between the environment and the right to an adequate standard of living, expressly stating that this right encompasses access to “food, water and housing” and that the adverse effects of climate change can interfere with the effective enjoyment of these rights. The Court further emphasized the necessity of adopting appropriate measures to protect the climate system and other parts of the environment, including adaptation measures and regulatory action, stating that “the full enjoyment of human rights cannot be ensured without the protection of the climate system and other parts of the environment” (ICJ, 2025). Accordingly, in areas where climate change contributes to an increased risk of subsidence by intensifying water stress, the State’s obligation to prevent and reduce such risks can be analyzed in conjunction with its obligations concerning climate adaptation and the protection of human rights, particularly the right to adequate housing.
Although effective prevention of land subsidence must primarily be based on sound water consumption management and the restoration of groundwater resources, achieving this objective requires long-term planning and sustained action. Consequently, in the short term, merely reducing groundwater extraction and waiting for subsidence to gradually diminish or cease is insufficient. Existing buildings and infrastructure in areas exposed to subsidence risks must also be protected. In this regard, structural retrofitting and foundation rehabilitation can help reduce the severity of damage caused by subsidence. For both existing buildings and new structures, appropriate foundation design and reinforcement techniques, the use of more suitable foundation systems, and measures to increase structural rigidity can be considered according to the level of risk and prevailing ground conditions. Therefore, alongside the long-term strategy of water resource management, structural retrofitting should be pursued as a short-term measure to reduce the vulnerability of buildings to land subsidence (Payab & Sayyaf, 2022).
- The Obligation to Ensure Safe Relocation Where Necessary and Provide Adequate Alternative Housing for Residents of High-Risk Areas
As discussed in the preceding subsection, the State’s response to the risk of land subsidence should primarily focus on continuous land monitoring, subsidence prevention, and risk reduction, particularly through optimal water resource management. Nevertheless, in certain areas, the severity or persistence of subsidence may reach a level at which continued residence poses serious threats to the safety and health of inhabitants. Under such circumstances, evacuation, relocation, and resettlement become relevant considerations. However, relocation should not be regarded as the State’s initial response to the existence of a hazard. Rather, it can be justified only where a serious risk has been established and less restrictive measures are insufficient to ensure residents’ safety. From this perspective, human rights experience concerning natural disasters and climate change can provide an appropriate framework for examining the State’s obligations in such circumstances. Although land subsidence is not itself a climatic phenomenon and does not necessarily share the same nature or causes as natural disasters, certain factors contributing to it may be associated with the consequences of climate change.
In her 2011 report on the realization of the right to adequate housing in post-disaster settings, the Special Rapporteur on Adequate Housing emphasized that where forced eviction has been established, affected individuals must have access to remedies, including restitution of housing or land, adequate compensation, or alternative housing and land. Furthermore, even where evacuation and relocation become necessary because of a genuine and serious threat to public safety, the State is required to comply with human rights safeguards, provide opportunities to challenge such measures and seek judicial review, and adopt the necessary measures to ensure access to alternative housing or accommodation for individuals unable to secure housing independently. The right to adequate housing encompasses several essential elements, including security of tenure; availability of services, materials, facilities, and infrastructure; affordability; habitability; accessibility; location; and cultural adequacy. Consequently, when relocation becomes necessary due to an environmental hazard, moving individuals to another building does not necessarily constitute fulfillment of the right to adequate housing unless the housing and living conditions at the new location are also taken into account (Rolnik, 2011).
Accordingly, safe relocation must involve transferring individuals to an environment that genuinely enables them to enjoy adequate living conditions, rather than merely moving them physically from one location to another. Furthermore, participation, non-discrimination, and equality must be respected throughout all stages of disaster response. The importance of this approach becomes particularly apparent when considering individuals who lack formal property ownership. The Special Rapporteur warns that many reconstruction and resettlement programs make proof of ownership or formal tenure a prerequisite for receiving assistance. As a result, tenants, residents of informal settlements, and individuals holding customary or informal forms of tenure may be excluded from reconstruction and permanent housing programs. However, security of tenure under the right to adequate housing is not synonymous with private property ownership, and various forms of lawful and legitimate tenure may exist. Therefore, when residents of high-risk areas are relocated, the State must also recognize and protect their previous tenure arrangements, and the absence of formal title deeds must not result in their exclusion from alternative housing. This consideration is particularly important for poor and vulnerable groups, who are often more likely than others to reside in high-risk areas (Rolnik, 2011).
Moreover, land subsidence cannot be analyzed exclusively through the framework of sudden-onset disasters such as earthquakes or floods. It can develop gradually through the interaction of natural and human factors and therefore shares certain characteristics, particularly regarding displacement-related consequences, with other slow-onset environmental hazards. The United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, in the Analytical Study on the Relationship between Human Rights and the Environment, also addresses environmental factors contributing to human displacement, including environmental degradation and “slow onset disasters,” such as desertification, subsidence in coastal areas, and increasing salinization of groundwater and soil (United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, 2011). This classification demonstrates that displacement caused by environmental hazards is not necessarily confined to sudden events, as gradual processes can also create conditions that compel populations to leave their places of residence. Accordingly, this framework can be used to analyze displacement resulting from land subsidence without necessarily placing the phenomenon directly within any one of these categories.
This relationship is also significant in the context of climate change. CESCR General Comment No. 27 provides that States must prevent climate-induced displacement by strengthening adaptation, disaster risk reduction, and other climate-related measures. Where relocation or resettlement becomes unavoidable to protect life and health, it must be undertaken only as a last resort, in accordance with international human rights standards and through meaningful consultation with affected communities. Furthermore, displaced persons must continue to enjoy equal access to rights such as water, housing, healthcare, education, and livelihoods (CESCR, 2025).
The United Nations Human Rights Council has also established more specific standards governing relocation and resettlement in the context of natural disasters and climate change. Recognizing that vulnerable individuals are disproportionately exposed to recurring displacement, “evictions without adequate remedies,” and exclusion from meaningful consultation and participation, to the detriment of their enjoyment of the right to adequate housing, the Council emphasized that all affected persons, without discrimination and regardless of their pre-disaster tenure status, must have access to housing that meets the requirements of adequacy, including habitability, security of tenure, suitable location, access to essential services, and compliance with safety standards. Affected individuals and communities must also have access to information and opportunities for meaningful consultation and participation in the planning and implementation of shelter and housing assistance (Human Rights Council, 2012). Furthermore, where relocation becomes necessary due to land subsidence, the State cannot consider its obligations fulfilled merely by issuing an evacuation order. Permanent relocation must be kept to a minimum wherever possible and undertaken only after alternative and less disruptive options have been considered. Where continued residence poses a serious threat to public safety, relocation must be carried out in accordance with international law. At the same time, the State must provide adequate alternative housing or shelter for individuals unable to secure accommodation independently and guarantee their access to appropriate remedies and a fair hearing (Human Rights Council, 2012). Therefore, the principal criterion governing relocation caused by land subsidence is not simply the movement of populations but the guarantee of safe relocation to adequate housing. Such relocation must be guided by necessity and proportionality, residents’ participation, non-discrimination, security of tenure, and the preservation of their access to essential services and basic living conditions.
Iranian Government Policies and Challenges Concerning the Impacts of Land Subsidence on the Right to Adequate Housing
Despite the various obligations established under existing laws and programs, the increasing prevalence of land subsidence in Iran demonstrates that current policies have yet to achieve the necessary coordination among water resource management, control of the factors contributing to subsidence, and protection of settlements exposed to risk. Under these circumstances, examining recent government and parliamentary policies, together with the challenges associated with their implementation, is particularly important for assessing the extent to which the right to adequate housing is being realized.
The National Disaster Management Law, enacted in 2019, explicitly recognized land subsidence as a hazard requiring attention within a framework emphasizing forecasting, prevention, and risk reduction. It obligated the responsible authorities to identify areas exposed to subsidence risks, develop appropriate engineering measures to address the phenomenon, and assess the safety of major buildings and the vulnerability of transportation infrastructure and critical lifelines to subsidence (National Disaster Management Law, 2019). Furthermore, the Law on Equitable Distribution of Water Resources, enacted in 1983, established an important legal basis for regulating groundwater extraction by placing groundwater resources under government authority and assigning the State responsibility for their protection, as well as for authorizing and supervising their exploitation. Given the role of excessive groundwater extraction in intensifying land subsidence, these responsibilities constitute preventive measures relevant to addressing the phenomenon (Law on Equitable Distribution of Water Resources, 1983).
One of the most significant recent initiatives addressing land subsidence is the proposed legislation entitled Control of Land Subsidence and Reduction of Its Impacts in the Country, which originated from the Supreme Council of Provinces. Following a proposal by the Islamic City Council of Tehran and a series of expert meetings involving specialists and relevant stakeholders, the proposal was approved in 12 articles at the fourteenth session of the Supreme Council of Provinces. It was subsequently approved by the Council of Ministers in March 2023 and submitted to the Islamic Consultative Assembly (Iranian Parliament) for consideration through the legislative process. The proposal was introduced during the eleventh parliamentary term, but the process leading to its final adoption was not completed. During the twelfth parliamentary term, a revised version, under the same title, was reconsidered, and its general principles were approved by the Parliamentary Committee on Agriculture, Water, Natural Resources and Environment on 20 April 2025. According to a 2025 report by the Parliament Research Center and statements published in 2026, expert assessments and revisions to the proposal continued, and its submission to the parliamentary plenary remained contingent upon completion of the outstanding procedural stages. Accordingly, based on the documents examined, the proposal cannot yet be regarded as legislation in force and must instead be described as a legislative proposal still under consideration (Payab, 2023; Hashemi, 2026). One of the principal objectives of the proposal is to establish coordination among the various government bodies and define their respective responsibilities concerning land subsidence more clearly. The proposed institutional framework envisages the establishment of a National Working Group on Land Subsidence, chaired by the Minister of Interior, alongside provincial working groups, as well as the allocation of specific responsibilities to executive authorities. This approach is particularly important because land subsidence does not fall within the jurisdiction of a single institution or specialized sector. Rather, its management simultaneously involves water resources, agriculture, construction, transportation, urban management, environmental protection, and disaster management. The proposal assigns various government bodies responsibilities relating to the regulation of groundwater extraction, reform of water consumption patterns, watershed management measures, and prevention of further subsidence. In the field of urban management, it also addresses issues such as revising building regulations and increasing water recycling. Thus, if adopted and effectively implemented, the proposal could facilitate greater coordination between measures aimed at reducing land subsidence and those designed to protect residential areas.
Nevertheless, the expert assessment conducted by the Parliament Research Center regarding the same proposal presents a more cautious perspective. Mahsa Payab, a researcher at the Islamic Consultative Assembly Research Center, argues that the principal challenge facing Iran in addressing land subsidence lies less in the absence of legislation than in weaknesses in implementing and enforcing existing laws and monitoring compliance with them. From this perspective, adopting new legislation would be beneficial only if the shortcomings of previous programs, particularly the Groundwater Resources Restoration and Balancing Program, were first systematically assessed and the new law established more effective enforcement and oversight mechanisms. She further maintains that certain provisions of the proposed legislation overlap or conflict with existing laws and policy documents, while the responsibilities assigned to the proposed working groups also overlap in some respects with those of the National Working Group on Adaptation to Water Scarcity. Accordingly, revising the proposal’s provisions, making use of existing institutional capacities, and avoiding the establishment of parallel bodies are necessary to enhance its prospects for effective implementation (Payab, 2023).
Given that the final text and complete details of the proposed legislation have not been made publicly available, it is not possible to determine with certainty the extent to which it addresses the effects of land subsidence on human settlements. Nevertheless, considering the direct relationship between land subsidence and housing safety and habitability, policies designed to address this phenomenon must also take account of residents living in areas exposed to serious risks. Where the severity of the danger makes continued residence impossible, the State must establish, in advance, the necessary mechanisms for safe evacuation, relocation, and the provision of adequate alternative housing. Such measures must not be limited to the physical relocation of residents but must also preserve their access to essential services, security of tenure, and adequate living conditions. From this perspective, government preparedness for the potential relocation of residents from high-risk areas constitutes an essential component of the policies required to protect the right to adequate housing against the consequences of land subsidence.
Conclusion
Land subsidence in Iran, given its geographical extent and its relationship with water resource exploitation practices, is not merely a technical or environmental issue but a phenomenon that can directly affect the realization of the right to adequate housing. When subsidence compromises the safety, structural stability, and habitability of buildings, the enjoyment of adequate housing is placed at risk, and in severe cases, continued residence may become impossible. Accordingly, the State’s obligations concerning this right must also encompass the provision of housing or compensation for damage after it occurs.
An examination of the legal foundations demonstrates that the State has, on the one hand, an obligation to monitor, prevent, and reduce the risks associated with land subsidence and, on the other, a duty to establish the necessary conditions for safe relocation and the provision of adequate alternative housing where the relocation of residents from high-risk areas becomes necessary. Sustainable water resource management, prevention of excessive groundwater extraction, reform of development and land-use patterns, continuous monitoring of areas exposed to risk, and structural retrofitting of buildings are among the most important preventive measures in this regard. Where continued residence poses serious risks, relocation must be undertaken only as a last resort and in accordance with the standards governing the right to adequate housing.
In Iran, although existing legislation, including the National Disaster Management Law and the Law on Equitable Distribution of Water Resources, provides a legal framework for preventing and controlling the factors contributing to land subsidence, and the new legislative proposal on subsidence control seeks to enhance coordination among the responsible authorities, the principal challenges remain the effective implementation of laws, regulatory oversight, institutional coordination, and sustainable water resource management. Accordingly, safeguarding the right to adequate housing against the consequences of land subsidence requires, more than the adoption of new regulations, the effective enforcement of existing legislation, the elimination of overlapping institutional responsibilities, the establishment of clearly defined mechanisms for protection and compensation, and the development of relocation and resettlement arrangements for residents of high-risk areas. Within such a framework, policies addressing land subsidence must move beyond a reactive, damage-oriented approach and become an integral part of the State’s comprehensive policy for the preventive protection of the right to adequate housing.
References
- The Holy Qur’an.
- Bagheri, M., Mokhtari Hashi, H., Gandomkar, A., & Khademolhosseini, A. (2022). The effect of water crisis on the destruction of the foundations of life: Case study of land subsidence in Isfahan Province. Journal of Space Political Planning, 4(4), 363–386.
- CESCR. (1990). General Comment No. 3: The Nature of States Parties’ Obligations (Article 2, Paragraph 1, of the Covenant). E/1991/23. CESCR. from: https://docs.un.org/en/E/1991/23
- CESCR. (1991). General Comment No. 4: The Right to Adequate Housing (Art. 11 (1) of the Covenant). UN Doc. E/1992/23, Annex III. CESCR. from: https://docs.un.org/en/E/1992/23
- CESCR. (2025). General Comment No. 27: on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and the Environmental Dimension of Sustainable Development. United Nations. from: https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4092192
- Civil Code of Iran. (1928).
- Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran. (1989).
- Fatholahi, N., Akhoondzadeh Hanzaei, M., & Bahroudi, A. (2018). Study of land subsidence due to oil extraction using radar interferometry (InSAR). Geographical Data (SEPEHR), 27(105), 23–34. https://doi.org/10.22131/sepehr.2018.31470
- Hashemi, P. (2026, January 20). Aghamiri, head of the City Council’s Construction Committee: The “Land Subsidence Control and Impact Reduction” bill will soon be presented to the parliamentary plenary session / Responsibilities of all agencies have been specified in the bill / A National Land Subsidence Working Group will be established. Didban Iran. From: https://www.didbaniran.ir/fa/tiny/news-264769
- Hesarakizad, A., Yamani, M., & Goorabi, A. (2024). Comprehensive analysis of land subsidence in Iran: A systematic review of current status. Quantitative Geomorphological Researches, 13(3), 23–45. https://doi.org/10.22034/gmpj.2023.401286.1441
- Housing Production Leap Law. (2021). Islamic Republic of Iran
- Human Rights Council. (2012). Adequate Housing as a Component of the Right to an Adequate Standard of Living in the Context of Disaster Settings. A/HRC/RES/19/4. UN. from: https://docs.un.org/A/HRC/RES/19/4
- (2025). Advisory Opinion on the Obligations of States in Respect of Climate Change. ICJ. from: https://www.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/case-related/187/187-20250723-adv-01-00-en.pdf
- International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966).
- Karimi, M., Ghanbari, A. A., & Amiri, S. (2013). Assessing the risks of land subsidence to urban settlements: A case study of District 18 of Tehran. Spatial Planning (Geography), 3(1), 37–56.
- Law on Equitable Distribution of Water Resources. (1983). Islamic Republic of Iran
- Law on Organizing and Supporting the Production and Supply of Housing of Iran. (2008).
- National Disaster Management Law. (2019). Islamic Republic of Iran
- Payab, M. (2023). Expert opinion on the bill concerning the control of land subsidence and reduction of its impacts in the country (Proposal of the Supreme Council of Provinces). Tehran: Islamic Consultative Assembly Research Center. https://doi.org/10.22034/report.2023.9857
- Payab, M., & Sayyaf, H. (2022). The impact of land subsidence on infrastructure and strategies for mitigating its effects. Tehran: Islamic Consultative Assembly Research Center.
- Rolnik, R. (2011). Report of the Special Rapporteur on Adequate Housing as a Component of the Right to an Adequate Standard of Living and on the Right to Non-Discrimination in This Context. A/66/270. United Nations. from: https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/710032
- Saadat-Maqam, M., & Iranpour Mobarakeh, M. (2025). A review of land subsidence and its consequences for civil engineering. Road Journal, 33(2), 413–424. https://doi.org/10.22034/road.2025.462350.2293
- Shafiei Darafshani, A., & Shamsi Ezhieh, A. (2024). Investigating the vulnerability and resilience of Isfahan City against the phenomenon of land subsidence. MANZAR, 16(69), 24–37. https://doi.org/10.22034/manzar.2024.457486.2285
- United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights. (2011). Analytical study on the relationship between human rights and the environment: Report of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (UN Doc. A/HRC/19/34). UN. https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/718748
- United Nations Treaty Collection. (2026). Status of Treaties: International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. United Nations. from: https://treaties.un.org/Pages/ViewDetails.aspx?chapter=4&mtdsg_no=IV-3&src=TREATY&clang=_en
- Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948).
- Urban Land Law. (1987). Islamic Republic of Iran
- Urban Wasteland Ownership Law. (1979). Islamic Republic of Iran






